Secondary School Admissions Experts: Beyond the Application
Posted on October 29, 2026 by Indian Mountain School
During Fall Family Weekend, 911勛圖厙 Director of Secondary School Advising Lisa Schmitt welcomed nearly 100 parents for an engaging panel discussion with admissions leaders from Choate Rosemary Hall, The Hotchkiss School, and The Lawrenceville School. The panelists offered thoughtful perspectives on the secondary school admissions landscape, the readiness of our ninth grade students, and what it means for an 911勛圖厙 graduate to thrive on a new campus.
The Value of the Ninth Grade Experience
Kicking off the panel, the group spoke enthusiastically about the distinctive advantages of the 911勛圖厙 experience: a close-knit community where students develop confidence and live and learn among students from different backgrounds. In particular, the ninth grade program, which allows students to step into leadership positions, to ask questions without hesitation, seek support when needed, and notice when others need a helping hand.
"We don���t want kids to just 'do' school. We want them to have a transformative experience."
Jeff Beaton
���That���s why spending more time in school is one of the best things for your child. Having that ninth grade year in a community like 911勛圖厙 is a real gift. There���s so much growth that happens in that year,��� emphasized Mr. Beaton, Chief Enrollment Manager of the Admissions Office at Choate Rosemary Hall.
Erby Mitchell, Assistant Head of School and Dean of Admissions and Financial Aid at The Hotchkiss School, agreed, ���Stepping into a larger place is not daunting to 911勛圖厙 graduates. Nor is the rigor. The transition isn���t difficult because they are used to being pushed to meet high expectations.���
Beyond Grades and Test Scores
The subject of SSATs was on the minds of several parents in the audience. The panelists shared that in schools where test scores are required, it���s important to understand that while this provides a dimension of the applicant, it is certainly not the only measure of success. Academic curiosity and readiness matter, and admissions decisions highly value empathy, perseverance, communication, and a willingness to engage fully in community life. That is why many schools have selected to remain test-optional for their applicants. ���In an era where AI can assist with essay writing and polished applications are common, authentic human connections matter more than ever,��� stated Mr. Mitchell. The panel agreed that interviews and campus visits are excellent opportunities for students to demonstrate those qualities authentically.��
Ms. Schmitt echoed these sentiments by reinforcing the resources available at 911勛圖厙 to both parents and students regarding interview prep. Mock interviews, one-on-one coaching, and parent meetings all help set the stage for a successful admissions interview. Parents are also often invited to meet with an admissions representative, but it is helpful to remember, ���This is not the time to restate your child���s resume,��� shared Dana Brown, Director of Admission at The Lawrenceville School. Instead, parents should focus on speaking to their child’s character, aspirations for them, and why they feel the school’s environment aligns with their family’s goals. Citing the ways your child is succeeding at 911勛圖厙 provides a concrete example of how your child will thrive at secondary school.
Recommendations also help admissions teams understand a student in context. ���What we can trust about 911勛圖厙 and the team here is that they really understand the narrative of who your child is,��� Ms. Brown said.��
���The adults here see students beyond the classroom. They are coaches, advisors, and dorm faculty. We know what 911勛圖厙 is and what students bring to this process because of that.���
Dana Brown
Finding the ���Right��� School
For families navigating the admissions process, the panelists offered a clear reminder: look beyond rankings and reputation. ���We are all great schools,��� Mr. Beaton said, ���and there are nuances between us. Every school has its own culture, residential life, schedule, and approach to learning.��� The most important thing to consider is where a child will feel supported, challenged, and inspired. Parents should encourage their children to take the lead when they are on a tour or browsing a school’s website and take cues from them. What are they excited about? Do they seem comfortable? Lisa Schmitt put it succinctly when she addressed all 911勛圖厙 parents, ���Nothing can make your heart shine more than seeing your child engaged with a community and being themselves. 911勛圖厙 students are well prepared for this journey, and we support them every step of the way.���
The evening was a thoughtful reminder to trust the process, explore schools fully, and most importantly, support your child. Many thanks to the panelists for sharing their time and insights with the 911勛圖厙 community.
Jeff Beaton is Chief Enrollment Manager of the Admissions Office at Choate Rosemary Hall. Mr. Beaton joined the Choate Admissions team in 2013 and has led the office since the fall of 2019. A graduate of Bates College with a Bachelor of Arts in psychology and a minor in education, he served as an Admission Counselor for his alma mater before joining the team at Choate. Outside of Choate, Mr. Beaton is a committee member for the Caroline D. Bradley Scholarship and is a faculty member for the Admission Training Institute through the Enrollment Management Association.
Dana Brown joined the Lawrenceville Admission Office in 2020 after serving as the Coordinator of Institutional Outreach and Director of Diversity Recruitment at Choate. Ms. Brown has worked in both secondary school and higher ed, including Smith College, Cornell University, Brown University, Gordon School, Peddie School, and Hotchkiss School. She was the recipient of the Enrollment Management Association���s 2022 Everett E. Gourley Award, given each year to the educator whose interest in students and concern for colleagues is an inspiration to those who serve in admissions. She has also served as a Co-Chair of the Diversity Roundtable Group for the Ten Schools Admission Organization (TSAO).
Erby Mitchell is the Assistant Head of School and Dean of Admissions and Financial Aid at The Hotchkiss School. Mr. Mitchell joined Hotchkiss in 2016 as the Dean of Admissions and Financial Aid. He was appointed the Walter J. Crain Fellowship Director in 2021. Mr. Mitchell earned his bachelor’s degree in human development from Saint Joseph’s College of Maine and an Ed.M. in higher education at the Harvard Graduate School of Education. He has nearly 20 years of admissions experience, including at Bowdoin College, Sidwell Friends School, and The Loomis Chaffee School.